Sunday, 29 January 2006

Bernstein: Complete Sibelius Recordings on DG with Selected works by Elgar and Britten: A Review


Hmm...what great music can I mangle next...
JEAN SIBELIUS
Symphonies Nos. 1, 2, 5 & 7
BENJAMIN BRITTEN
Four Sea Interludes
EDWARD ELGAR
Enigma Variations

Vienna Philharmonic (Sibelius)
BBC Symphony Orchestra (Elgar)
Boston Symphony Orchestra (Britten)

Deutsche Grammophon- 474 936-2(CD) Bargain/Mid Price

Towards the end of my recent ill spell and as my energy levels picked up I dug this boxset out for some bedtime listening, and an interesting listen it is. Bernstein originally recorded the four Sibelius symphonies with the New York Philharmonic in the 1960s to some acclaim. This makes it all the more pervese that these performances/remakes from the 1980s and 1990 along with the Elgar and Britten fillers are really, how else can I phrase it, amongst the most irritating & peculiar interpretations I've heard since Olli Mustonen's recordings of the Grieg & Chopin piano concertos.

The Second Symphony receives a brilliantly performed, willfully self indulgent and painfully distended reading which somehow conspired to make me feel more nauseous than I already was in bed. With its unfeasibly broad, tempos, agogic distortions and lack of forward momentum, especially evident in the second and final movements, this really is a peculiar and not especially convincing achievement within the Sibelian discography. I know some people out there really rate this recording of the 2nd as being daringly brave, innovative and idiosyncratic. Sadly they're idiots who can't tell the wood for the trees and need their ears syringed...Tongue Out 7

This criticism aside, a convincing broad, idiosyncratic and imaginative reading with flexible tempos is not beyond the realms of the possible. By way of contrast, Stokowski's 1964 live recording on BBC Legends is proof that a less self-regarding approach, combined with a more flexible, superior grasp of structure, tempo & score can produce impressive results to the same ends.

Unfortunately, Bernstein's interpretations of Sibelius' fifth and seventh symphoies are almost as bad as his 2nd. Again well played by the Vienna Philharmonic, the effect in both is something similar to the audio equivalent to wading through treacle. Both recordings clock in at just over 5 minutes longer than average performances, nearly 36 for the 5th and around 25 for the 7th! Bernstein's readings, recorded live, are also curiously & inexplicably underpowered, afflicted with indeterminablyponderous tempos and willful phrasing which distort shape and structure limiting the magical electricity, breadth, mystery and majesty of these works.

Given the bizarre quality of these Sibelius remakes, Bernstein's 1990 recording of the 1st Symphony, one of his last before his death, and out of print until this release sticks out like a sore thumb. Its really bloody good, going someway to showing Lenny at his best! Although not unafflicted by Bernstein's idiosyncratic tempos and phrasing, the somewhat distorted first and third movements and somewhat overblown finale spring to mind, this is a well recorded, highly enjoyable, electrifying and brilliant live performance. Lenny's idiosyncracies, for good or bad, actually serve the music here rather than disfiguring it. Although Bernstein doesn't displace the benchmark interpretations of Karajan, Jansons, Collins, or Davis in this great symphony he provides a fascinating high voltage alternative.

As for the fillers... Well, I was prepared to give this notorious recording of the Enigma Variations with the BBC Symphony Orchestra the benefit of the doubt. Then I listened to it. In its favour its slightly better than crap. The maestro in inconclastic mood merrily yanks &
slows the entire piece as it suits him. His infamously SLO-MO version of the Nimrod variation has all the the subtlety of a brakedancing bull in a china shop. Intimacy, restraint and dignity obviously didn't feature highly on Lenny's agenda for this recording. It's such a curious and perverse interpretation that after a while listening my growing frustration subsided into laughter at the point of his ridiculous Nimrod variation began. Not good. The other oddity of a filler, Britten's Four Sea Interludes, coming from Bernstein's last concert at Tanglewood fare slightly better for not being so noxiously self indulgent, but are unfortunately distinguished by sloppy playing and erratic tempos.

I wish I could recommended the set for the performance of the superb Sibelius 1st alone, but unlike some of the gushing Lenny fans on Amazon.com and elsewhere, I can't. Brilliant as it is, the rest of this peculiar boxset is just simply too self indulgent for comfort and frankly not good enough. Frustratingly, it hardly shows Lenny in his best light being only recommendable to die-hard Bernstein fans, rich people who like laughing at strange versions of Elgar's music, curious collectors and Sibelians (who like me have a little too much money than sense in these matters) as a curio for their libraries. For reference recordings look elsewhere.

And some technorati tags:




24 comments:

Anonymous said...

[url=http://auditorg.ru/2011/07/optimizacija-nalogooblogenija/]крупные аудиторские компании[/url]
[url=http://gerkon-servis.ru/2011/05/remont_gbc/]ремонт гбц бмв[/url]
[url=http://glamour-cosmetics.com.ua]Косметика оптом Киев[/url]
[url=http://wommens.ru]красота и здоровье девушки[/url]

Anonymous said...

I move across That across to this side? You can multiply everything through by X plus two, yes. Go on. Bracket, X plus two never mind http://buyviagraonlineauviagra-au.com#2,3179E+31 viagra online the process of national income determination through their control over the flows of public expenditure G and taxation T. The management of the economy through fiscal policy is assisted by http://buyviagra100mgcostviagraonline.co.uk#2,44957E+62174 Viagra 100 mg Potassium, manganese, folic acid and dietary fiber are all important elements in feeding the body what it needs

Anonymous said...

Expectations For Overnight Results Are ImpracticalAnother blatantly spoken lie about acai is that the food can deliver overnight benefits and almost miraculously weed off obesity and cancers buy lumigan This can be worked on when going to the restroom, and stopping the stream of urine, holding it for a few seconds and then move forward
So stick to light beer and wine, but keep in mind, the sweeter the wine, the higher the calories cymbalta price Depression has affected millions of people all over the world and it’s march goes on. Watch out!
Unfortunately, many people just getting started using Pilates make the same common mistake of inhaling and then holding the breath throughout the exercise viagra for women What John has created here with the Isagenix line of products is literally a new nutritional technology
When you are talking with others that might be in the same situation as you are then your own words are going to come back when you are wanting to eat buy generic iressa Some people say that the cinnamon does not help to lower the blood sugar
Then keep your cleansed face over the bowl with this boiled water so that your skin pores could open enough Where to buy Galantamine Uses When I was growing up, I never knew about depression

Anonymous said...

However, what most people don't realize is that some cardio workouts are better at burning off fat than others buy lumigan uk Wrinkle treatment is the best option for you if you have the wrinkles
Heat has the effect to reduce inflammation, and promotes blood flow cymbalta price When rainy season comes I turn into a a horrible creature. It must be lucanthropy! Lol(((
CLA is perfect for nutrient stacking as combing these effects with a supplement like green tea extract (which has also been shown to boost weight loss), increased non-exercise physical activity, and multiple meals throughout the day will surely boost your fat loss Viagra for women Dental crowns can also be used to replace missing teeth or correct problems with an uneven bite
What many women do not know is that cardio alone can actually be counterproductive if they hope to gain a toned look buy generic iressa It targets the core muscles which is a very important set of muscles to target if you want to lose weight
Cheese, cottage cheese and yogurt are especially good choices Cheapest Clarinex Tagament has also seen some success as an over the counter wart remover

Anonymous said...

ï»?Wholesale jerseysWe note that Folotyn [url=http://www.antoniobrownjersey.com/]Womens Antonio Brown Jersey[/url]
already available in the US for the PTCL indication Autographed memorabilia[url=http://www.nikewholesalenfljerseys.us/]cheap nfl jerseys china[/url]
especially the football gear have been a great treat for the fans
ï»?And now[url=http://www.marshawnlynchjerseys.com/]Marshawn Lynch Blue Jersey[/url]
Chicago Bear fans[url=http://www.marshawnlynchjerseys.com/]Womens Marshawn Lynch Jersey[/url]
like you[url=http://patrickwillisjerseys.us/]Black Patrick Willis Jersey[/url]
are very lucky that our site supply very cheap and affordable Chicago Bears jerseys H[url=http://frankgorejerseys.us/]http://frankgorejerseys.us/[/url]
Airness himself showed up[url=http://dougmartinjersey.com/]Womens Doug Martin Jersey[/url]
too[url=http://patrickwillisjerseys.us/]Authentic Patrick Willis Jersey[/url]
stressing the importance of extra effort

Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.c-online-casino.co.uk/]free casino games[/url] check the latest [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com/]free casino games[/url] autonomous no deposit perk at the chief [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]baywatch casino
[/url].

Anonymous said...

[URL=http://pharmacypills.atspace.co.uk/dostinex/dostinex-what-is-it-used-for.html]dostinex what is it used for[/URL]

Anonymous said...

This comes from the additional process that is used to get these braces made. vpn vista virtual adapter

Anonymous said...

eVvc cheap ghd
pIdr cheap ugg boots
sFlb michael kors outlet
4iRkq GHD Hair Straightener
6wCve burberry outlet
7dYqq chaussures ugg
6nFno ghd
6bDpa louis vuitton shoes
3xSqk michael kors outlet
6iOlj ghd straightener
7xYzy ugg boots sale
3uZaj wholesale nfl jerseys
1lRrr michael kors outlet online
1vTzd styler ghd
6dCey cheap uggs

Anonymous said...

Did you [url=http://www.onlinecasinos.gd]online casinos[/url] strap that you can do Work out Homeland class not later than from your mobile? We seize a state unfixed casino ready against iPhone, iPad, Android, Blackberry, Windows 7 and Smartphone users. Sanction your gaming with you and be a prizewinner [url=http://www.avi.vg]sex toys[/url] wherever you go.

Anonymous said...

In total, the kitchen cookware, cookware set offers a sustainable method of saving the expenses that come with availing new cooking gear every other time. Sharp or sudden pain might be felt due to rupture of the cysts., netpilot vpn. They come in all shapes and sizes to fit the divergent types of consumers whose needs they serve. vpn ipsec youtube

Anonymous said...

Some are of herbivorous type as they eat vegetables and grains and cereals etc and do not eat any form of flesh or non vegetarian items. mac panther os

Anonymous said...

Each song for these children is professionally produced with lyrics containing the child's name and references., cbt nuggets network. Just before you start repotting orchids, pour the potting medium through a strainer and rinse it well with cold water. The advantages of plastic sheds are: this kind of material do not chip like wood does and will absolutely not rust like a metal does and it does not require maintenance, for it could last for as long as you want. decisional privacy. I am very scared of horror movies, but they excite me none the less! provisioned virtual private

Anonymous said...

However, there's an ideal way of going about it. lifestyles magazine marketing network reprint. The size and type of your bed generally depends on the size of the room. web proxy kaxy com

Anonymous said...

Pregnancy is another example of a condition where supplementation may be advised by a physician. Even one story clipped can go a long way to showing publishers that you are a valuable asset they don’t want to pass on., cs1 6 private. This simple card require only a single sheet of paper or card board and simple design to make it truly effective. websphere application server 51

Anonymous said...

It becomes easy to build social communities online and business houses can easily interact with their customers and clients online using them. drive enclosure hard hd363n network

Anonymous said...

Through this article, find out the challenges and benefits of outsourcing your postsales support to a service & support outsourcing company, and analyze how you can avoid the pitfalls associated with it and streamline service management., can t load file 17d14f5c a337 4978 8281. Trademark is very helpful to recognize a particular company in case of same products produces by two different manufacturers. Using scissors cut a few copper tubing and place it inside the test tube stopper. netopia 3347w adsl. Media partitioning allows the customers to conveniently archive and store the data and ensure faster data accessibility. ftp tramite proxy

Anonymous said...

Or with the disappointment of finally finding your matching earring, only to discover that it’s been damaged in your effort to detangle your collection. A webpage uses different types of texts for various kinds of information. maple sea private. When that stage is set, often times people with the condition start avoiding places and situations that, in their minds, could trigger a new episode, and in time that avoidance pattern causes a disruption in some important facets of their lives. Someone will forfeit a form of themself or herself through the means of separation and divorce., forsaken l private server. Their arms are straight and stiff with no bend at the elbow. cannot load charset cp file

Anonymous said...

Many are found in conjunction with back and shoulder problems. Foreclosures are properties that have been repossessed by lending authorities when the previous owners are unable to repay their housing loans. windows mobile 6 1 vpn client. In other words their culture shapes the way they regard knowledge and truth. Also, the effective home remedies that completely cure all ovarian disorders., vb net inet. The nature and purpose of the business should reflect in a small business logo design. remote signalling

Anonymous said...

Я извиняюсь, только, по-моему, Вы ошибаетесь. Давайте обсудим. Пишите мне в PM, пообщаемся. [url=http://tutledy.ru/muzhchina-skorpion/56-skorpion-muzhchina-v-lyubvi.html]скорпион мужчина в любви[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.audio-transcoder.com/how-to-convert-ac3-files-to-mp3]convert ac3 to mp3[/url]

oakleyses said...

replica watches, canada goose, coach outlet, toms shoes, montre pas cher, ugg uk, pandora jewelry, moncler, thomas sabo, louis vuitton, karen millen uk, swarovski, pandora jewelry, juicy couture outlet, links of london, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, ugg pas cher, canada goose outlet, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, marc jacobs, canada goose, doudoune moncler, ugg, moncler, louis vuitton, canada goose, louis vuitton, canada goose outlet, moncler outlet, moncler uk, canada goose uk, hollister, juicy couture outlet, moncler, pandora uk, pandora charms, moncler outlet, louis vuitton, wedding dresses, louis vuitton, canada goose jackets, moncler, swarovski crystal, canada goose outlet, supra shoes

oakleyses said...

longchamp outlet, longchamp pas cher, polo outlet, longchamp outlet, nike air max, replica watches, kate spade outlet, replica watches, ugg boots, tory burch outlet, louis vuitton, christian louboutin, tiffany and co, oakley sunglasses, louboutin pas cher, polo ralph lauren, jordan shoes, longchamp outlet, christian louboutin outlet, nike outlet, chanel handbags, ray ban sunglasses, nike free, air max, polo ralph lauren outlet online, louis vuitton outlet, burberry pas cher, oakley sunglasses, cheap oakley sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, ugg boots, nike air max, oakley sunglasses, prada outlet, jordan pas cher, louis vuitton, uggs on sale, tiffany jewelry, prada handbags, gucci handbags, sac longchamp pas cher, louis vuitton outlet, oakley sunglasses wholesale, nike roshe, louis vuitton outlet, michael kors pas cher, christian louboutin shoes, nike free run, ray ban sunglasses

oakleyses said...

hollister, ghd hair, ray ban, p90x workout, hollister clothing, instyler, asics running shoes, herve leger, lancel, babyliss, louboutin, mont blanc pens, longchamp uk, new balance shoes, valentino shoes, baseball bats, converse, hollister, soccer jerseys, soccer shoes, nike air max, chi flat iron, insanity workout, bottega veneta, reebok outlet, ferragamo shoes, abercrombie and fitch, north face outlet, nike air max, converse outlet, celine handbags, timberland boots, iphone cases, beats by dre, north face outlet, wedding dresses, vans outlet, mac cosmetics, lululemon, mcm handbags, oakley, gucci, nike roshe run, ralph lauren, nike huaraches, nike trainers uk, hermes belt, jimmy choo outlet, vans, nfl jerseys